Unlocking High Standards: How This Senior Program Manager Measures Performance and Customer Satisfaction
Loading Video...
Preparing the interview
Complete interview transcript & analysis below
Enhanced transcript with interviewer insights
INTERVIEWER
Um, so, you know, it is, it is highly likely, uh, that your target company will have you responsible for and using fairly cutting edge, uh, technologies and data analytics. I think that's a fair statement. Um, this means that you will likely be responsible for having to define performance metrics, uh, and other operational metrics, uh, to, to kind of manage the business and, and maintain or be a part of a high performing team. And so I, I'm curious to have you walk me through, uh, how you think about and determine. The appropriate targets that you set for either your team or yourself or your team collectively to ensure that you remain a high performing group, just walk me through your process.
CANDIDATE
For sure, uh, and I, in my experience comes from being more on the sales and and sales end. So what we first do is try to understand for our customers what, uh, the key areas that they care about when it comes to our product, so. For example, in, in, in our products and services, the two things that they cared about the most was a reliability and performance, and on the reliability end is where a lot of our operational pieces is put back together. So for example, uh, how do we measure, you know, effective reliability? Uh, that can be measured in a couple of ways. It could be measured in downtime, uh, it could be measured in a supply chain reliability. And it can also be measured in uh essentially how quickly are we responding. Laying to our customer needs, and, and that, for, for that metric was a little trickier. Downtime and uh supply chain reliability are pretty easy metrics that you can track, but measuring um. How happy customers are and how receptive they are, especially in an enterprise environment where you only have 10 customers, was a little tricky. So one of the ways that we did this was every quarter we would um send out, uh, with our marketing groups, develop surveys to measure essentially kind of a net promoter score type of metric and, and determine how we were doing on the levels of services that we provide, field services, supply chain services, technical consulting, etc. And with that, we would be able to track that over time and uh and basically push, push metrics to each individual units to say, hey, this is how we're performing with our key accounts on each individual metric.
Interviewer Insight
In my experience it's on the sales end. In our products and services what they cared about the most was reliability and performance. Re: Reliability - how do we measure effective reliability? Downtime? How quickly we are responding to our customer needs. Downtime and supply chain reliability are easy to track, but measuring how happy customers are is tricky. One thing we did for this was to work with our marketing groups and send out an NPS-like survey on the Q to our customers. We tracked this over time. This would allow us to communicate better internally the status with our customers.
INTERVIEWER
And so when you think about when you come up short. Right? You're, you're not quite hitting the, hitting your goals. What's your process for walking through this with your managers or manager, sorry. Like how do you, how do you raise that, that issue? How do you, how do you communicate that?
CANDIDATE
Yeah, the first thing that, that, that's important to have is uh adequate insight into the data, so especially when you're dealing with qualitative data, uh, the best way that I help tackle uh those sort of issues is by a trending it over time. And then trying to relate it down to uh the quantitative numbers and, and what that means for the business, uh, for example, a disgruntled customer uh may be responsible for a specific key use case that's responsible for $10 of revenue in our business, and by relating into those terms that our managers can understand and, hey, what impact does that this have on our revenue stream, we can really get management buy-in. On putting together projects and initiatives to improve areas that we may be coming up short in.
INTERVIEWER
Well, sure, that, that's if you're trying to get buy-in for, for changes, I, I guess, but. What I'm actually more concerned about is, uh, problem coming, right? You identify an issue coming down the pipe. Um, how are you raising that, that a lot? What is your process for communicating? Not that you need to make changes, but more you're, you're like we're coming up short. Walk me through that.
CANDIDATE
Sure, so, uh, essentially how do I make a pro prevent a problem from snowballing into something bigger? Sure,
INTERVIEWER
we'll start with that, yeah.
CANDIDATE
Sure, uh. 11 key method that, that, that helps me, uh, once, so, so we're getting this data, it's coming in and, and we're tracking uh this problem throughout, so, so one example this happened was in a specific case where a customer was having, uh, essentially an electrical problem at a unit, and this unit was very small, it, it, uh, didn't account for a lot of our revenue on our side, and it wasn't a very big application for them either. But this customer was disgruntled. I mean, this, this was a problem that was going on for several months, and um I had recently overtaken this account and I was responsible for making this customer um satiated, but. Our management was not concerned with, with this, with this issue at all, mainly because You know, this was such a small piece of business for us that we didn't realize that that the impact that it could have, um, so one way that I, that I got involved in this project was by talking to the customer and understanding what this business meant to them and. Raising that red flag, uh, with, with our manager and our and our teams and being repeated about that process, uh, so not just, you know, mentioning it once in our, uh, weekly reviews, etc. but understanding, hey, this is what's happening, these are the steps we're taking, and constantly conveying those key action items and plans to our management. Uh, eventually, we were, eventually this, this problem related to that management buy-in issue that I was talking about earlier, to get some additional resources involved to help, uh, this customer resolve their, their key issues, but one way we were able to build up, um, some of those red flags was by, you know, continuously tracking the data and conveying and communicating to our teams what needed to be done to, to resolve it.
Interviewer Insight
Look for clear data and ability to have clear explanations. By presenting data as what-if for impact on our revenue streams we can get buy in for changes. As an example - we had an area where we were coming up short. I reached out to the customer to better understand what the business meant to them on the whole. Wanted more insight. Raised this within our team outside of our normal weekly cadence. We continuously track the data and communicate constantly.
INTERVIEWER
And so what happens when it's a called a partner team over whom you don't have direct managerial control isn't meeting expectations, but it's impacting you? How do you, how do you handle that situation?
CANDIDATE
Yeah, yeah, that's tough, and, and it happened a lot, I mean, uh, a lot of our projects required um lead times that were consistently um uh expanding, uh, throughout, throughout the course of our business. And uh I dealt with one manager who, you know, his, his main focus and and and uh priorities were uh cutting down costs and when you cut down costs, what you end up doing is likely is also um in, in our case expanding the lead times which which hurt our customer relationships. So, so how do we kind of manage, uh, two different competing priorities was the key issue, um, here the best way that I, that I, uh, worked through it was. Uh, to kind of come together and, and build teams and, and, and, and, and align objectives, uh, so, yeah, yeah, cutting costs is important, but if we're continuously hurting our customer relationships by expanding lead times, uh, well, that's gonna hurt our bottom line in, in a much greater extent if we happen to lose some of these accounts. Um, so, one thing that we did was come together as a team and collaboratively brainstorm these problems ahead of time and work together solutions to, to have a set target of, OK, what is the maximum lead time that we're comfortable with? What sort of messaging do we need to convey to customers so that they don't have expectations that are outside the limit, and, and we have to, and then to help. Uh, my partner's compromise, one thing that we ended up doing was trying to push forward together more standard offerings so that, uh, when you have more standard offerings, you reduce complexity, uh, reduce costs, and, uh, reduce lead times as well. So figuring out ways that we can compromise and and meet both objectives was critical.
Interviewer Insight
Happened a lot. Required lead times that were impacting many parts of the business. Had one manager who was super focused on cutting costs, which is essentially a way of expanding lead times. We had competing priorities. Worked with him to align objectives. Pointed out how lead times were impacting customer sat.
Interviewer Insight
note during interview: good use of defined metrics (lead time, customer sat) as tools for internal discussions.
Interviewer Insight
note: despite paying some lip service to the name metrics the candidate never delivered on the initial promise of their answer. This is a recurrent them in the interview thus far in that the candidate is not utilizing any specifics in relation to the actual metrics used.
Expert Assessment
Interviewer assessment - would be used in a hiring meeting
The candidate over-delivered relative to their level in presenting a framework for how they work to hold the line for standards within an organization. The answer was unsupported by any hard numbers to present a clear picture of how issues are raised, triaged, and prioritized. Without the hard metrics there is possibility that the candidate is repeating hindsight analysis of a situation rather than having lived and driven it. Benefit of the doubt will be given here for the candidate who, again, over-delivered relative to level. The missing metrics is presumed to be a stylistic unforced error.